The 22nd session of the dialogue series "Coaching Meets AI" focused on the following topics:
1. Empathy in AI Coaching:
- Discussion on the limitations of AI in conveying empathy. The session built on a previous discussion about the ability of AI to understand and simulate human emotions.
- Practical tests were proposed to evaluate the empathetic capabilities of AI models like ChatGPT.
2. Practical Test with ChatGPT:
- A test interaction was conducted where participants presented ChatGPT with emotionally challenging scenarios (e.g., "I was fired").
-
Results:
- ChatGPT responded with general empathy, objective suggestions, and a problem-solving focus.
- Criticism: Responses were sometimes too general and overly rational, failing to fully meet individual emotional needs.
- Positive aspect: ChatGPT's ability to clearly communicate its limitations, such as in providing deeper emotional support, was acknowledged.
3. Analysis of ChatGPT's Pattern:
- AI tends to generalize situations, offer a "supermarket" of options, and is programmed to respond with friendliness.
- A deeper emotional processing, such as targeted affect regulation, which a human coach could provide, is often missing.
4. Ethics Discussion:
- Pro: The AI behaves ethically, avoiding manipulation or emotionally harmful statements.
- Contra: There was criticism of potential "neglect of duty," particularly in cases of psychological issues, where the AI fails to refer users to human experts.
- Suggestions: Improved configuration of AI to provide more specific and relevant emotional support.
Concluding Discussion and Outlook:
- Proposals were made to develop systematic tests and benchmarks to objectively evaluate the empathy capabilities of various AI models.
- The integration of 3D environments and avatars in coaching scenarios was highlighted as an exciting area for exploration.
- Participants agreed to continue the discussion in the next session, potentially including prepared inputs for further developing the tests.
The session concluded with plans for an in-depth analysis and experimental approaches in the upcoming meeting.